|
4#

楼主 |
发表于 2013-11-8 10:57:18
|
只看该作者
评论
Subie - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 10:46 am
errr, one massive and obvious omission Roald Dahl! Wrote more well known & loved books than any in your list, and certainly ‘better’ than JK Rowling (unless this list is by an eight year old who has never read any Roald Dahl), that’s for sure!
绝对明显漏掉了罗尔德·达尔,他写的书比名单上的任何书都更受欢迎,当然也好过JK·罗琳了(除非这榜单是个没看过罗尔德·达尔任何作品的八岁孩子写的),那是肯定的。
(译注:罗尔德·达尔在中国最知名的儿童文学作品是《查理与巧克力工厂》,他写的成人短篇小说Man from the South多次被希区柯克和昆汀塔伦蒂诺等人改编为电影和电视剧,他还是007电影系列之雷霆谷的编剧,前妻是第36届奥斯卡最佳女主角得主Patricia Neal。Roald Dahl在世时因反犹而饱受争议。)
Ronne Randall - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 10:55 am
Where is A. A. Milne, with Winnie the Pooh and The House at Pooh Corner?! Before Disney got to them, these books were filled with joy, magic, poignancy, and adventure – true timeless classics.
写《小熊维尼》和《小熊维尼的小屋》的A. A. 米尔恩呢?在迪士尼改编以前,这部系列书充满了欢乐、魔力、辛辣和冒险,真正永恒的经典。
Ann - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 11:17 am
Seriously, Astrid Lindgren and Tove Jansson !?
认真地说,阿斯特里德·林格伦和托夫·杨森 !?
(译注:瑞典儿童文学女作家阿斯特里德·林格伦在中国最著名的作品是《长袜子皮皮》和《小飞人》)
(译注:芬兰女作家托夫·杨森曾作《木民谷》系列故事)
Teresa - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 11:30 am
I like this list. I know how hard it is to encompass something like ALL of children’s literature into a list of 10.
This is a pretty good start and I think you could add Robert Cormier, who wrote The Chocolate War and I am the Cheese.
我喜欢这榜单,我知道把所有儿童文学家汇总成一个只有10位作家的榜单有多难。这是个很好的开始,我想你应该把创作了《巧克力战争》和《我是奶酪》的罗伯特·科米尔加进榜单里。
(译注:《巧克力战争》与《麦田里的守望者》和《杀死一只知更鸟》齐名,是20世纪最具争议的青少年文学作品,至今仍长踞美国禁书榜榜首。罗伯特·科米尔喜写人性中黑暗面,他大部分作品中主角都以失败告终。)
Kerishma - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 11:37 am
Again, it’s hard to include everyone in a list of 10, but Roald Dahl seems like a glaring omission! And when I was a kid I loved LOVED the Junie B. Jones books by Barbara Park, as well as the books by Gail Carson Levine (who I guess would be better classified as YA…but still)
重复下,把这么多作家汇总成只有10位作家的榜单很困难,但明显遗漏了罗尔德·达尔!我还是小孩时那么爱巴巴拉·帕克写的《朱尼·琼斯》系列,还有盖尔·卡森·列文的作品(最好将其列为青少年读物,但还是推)。
(译注:盖尔·卡森·列文获纽奖作品《魔法灰姑娘》后改编为电影,由安妮·海瑟薇主演。)
Matt - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 11:59 am
Nicely done list — I mean, with the inclusion of Madeline L’Engle, Philip Pullman, and E. L. Koingsburg, it’s difficult to complain. Except of course with the exclusion of Norton Juster. Get rid of C. S. Lewis and include Juster.
Also, I’m glad to see J. K. Rowling included on here. Missing Roald Dahl is a bit of a disappointment, but I consider Rowling, particularly toward the end of the series (whether she needed a stronger editor or not) to be a much stronger writer than Dahl.
不错的榜单,有马德琳·英格、菲力普·普曼和E.L.柯尼斯伯格,很难说它不好,除了没有诺顿·贾斯特,把 C·S·刘易斯去掉换上贾斯特。
还有,很高兴J·K·罗琳在榜上。没有罗尔德·达尔有点小失望,我认为罗琳比达尔在系列作品的收尾上要强(不管前者是否需要配个强力编辑)。
(译注:诺顿·贾斯特:最知名的作品是《神奇的收费亭》,他写作并绘制插图的《点与线》被拍成电影,获得过奥斯卡最佳动画短片奖。)
Lindsay - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 12:02 pm
I love this gem. http://www.amazon.com/Who-Peed-Pumpkin-Joann-Brogan/dp/1448925975
我喜欢这本好书。http://www.amazon.com/Who-Peed-Pumpkin-Joann-Brogan/dp/1448925975
Zach - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 2:10 pm
Lets get one thing straight, CS Lewis towers above Pullman, there no comparison. Also, There are about 4 selections that could have been replaced with Kenneth Grahame.
直说吧,C·S·刘易斯比普曼强多了,两位没法比。而且肯尼斯·格雷厄姆能取代榜上4位作家。
(译注:英国儿童文学作家肯尼斯·格雷厄姆名作是《杨柳风》、《黄金时代》、《梦里春秋》)
Cynthia Leitich Smith - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 2:14 pm
A quick shout out to some of my favorite children’s authors of color–Rita Williams-Garcia, Grace Lin, Monica Brown, Jacqueline Woodson, Allen Say….I could go on and on.
我能马上叫出我最爱作家的名字:里塔·维威廉姆斯·加西亚、林珮思、莫尼卡·布朗、杰奎琳·武森、阿伦·赛…我还能继续说下去。
(译注:非裔作家里塔·维威廉姆斯·加西亚因《疯狂的夏天》获2011年纽伯瑞金奖。)
(译注:美国华裔绘本作家林珮思的《月夜仙踪》融合了多个中国传统神话故事,该书获得2010年纽伯瑞银奖。)
(译注:智利裔作家莫尼卡·布朗最知名作品是纪念加西亚·马尔克斯的《My name is Gabito》)
(译注:非裔作家杰奎琳·武森成名作是《麦克林的孩子们》)
(译注:日裔作家阿伦·赛成名作是《爷爷的旅行》)
Philip Nel - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 3:18 pm
Restricting myself to the 9-13 age range, some prominent missing authors: Christopher Paul Curtis, Roald Dahl, Jacqueline Woodson, Shaun Tan, Tove Jansson. I realize that it’s hard to include all in a top 10, so here are two you could cut: Lewis, & L’Engle. Both wrote for young readers, but how many of their books are great? Lion, the Witch, & the Wardrobe (for Lewis), and A Wrinkle in Time (L’Engle). But The Magician’s Nephew? Not so much.
年龄限制在9-13岁的话,还遗漏了几个知名作家:克里斯托弗·保罗·柯蒂斯、罗尔德·达尔、杰奎琳·武森、陈志勇和托夫·杨森。我想在所有作家中只列前十位是困难的,可以把刘易斯和英格删掉。都是给孩子的书,但他们有几本杰作呢?只有《纳尼亚传奇》和《时间的皱纹》。《魔术师的侄子》么?(C·S·刘易斯作)可不够好。
(译注:克里斯托弗·保罗·柯蒂斯的《我是巴德 不是巴弟》获2000年纽伯瑞金奖,他是首位获纽金奖的非裔男作家)
(译注:澳洲华裔插画家陈志勇的代表作是《观像镜》、《兔子》和《抵岸》。绘本《失物招领》改编后获2011年奥斯卡最佳动画短片奖。)
Gina - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 7:10 pm
I read THE GIVER in elementary school and loved it. I read it in high school and thought I understood all the symbolism. I read it again in college and discovered so much more. Now I read it to my kids and fell in love all over again. Thank you Lois Lowry for writing books that matter.
小学时读过《记忆传授人》,我特喜欢。高中读时我觉得明白了书中所有的象征意义,上大学再读理解又深了一层。现在我给自己的孩子读这本书还喜欢重温它,感谢洛伊丝·劳里的创作。
Jessica Leader - Tuesday Mar 20, 2012 at 7:10 pm
Hats off for naming Lowry as one of the Top 10! I’m rooting for her as a future ambassador of children’s literature. Among other things, she’s enormously versatile: realistic fiction, sci-fi, historical fiction; humor and tragedy; chapter books through middle-grade. In addition, while the above description celebrates her bravery in taking on complex topics, let’s also mention her humor! ANASTASIA AT THIS ADDRESS still makes me laugh harder than just about any book, and books like THE GIVER include funny moments as well. Happy birthday to one of my enduringly favorite writers, and thanks to her for working so hard to grace our shelves.
One peeve, though: No Walter Dean Myers??
欣赏前10榜单中提名劳里!我全力支持她成为儿童文学的未来大使。此外她还多才多艺:现实、科幻、历史体裁小说、悲喜剧及适合中高年级看的章回小说都拿手。还有,既然上文中赞扬她勇于创作复杂题材,让我们聊聊她的幽默吧!《我交了一个笔友》比任何书都搞笑,像《记忆传授人》这样的书中也有滑稽场面。祝我中意已久的作家生日快乐,感谢她努力写作给我们的书架增添了光彩。
只恼一点:为什么没有沃尔特·迪恩·迈尔??
(译注:沃尔特·迪恩·迈尔:知名非裔作家,涉及越战的《堕落天使》一书曾被禁。)
|
|