告诉你一些很多phonics教材存在的问题---兼谈SWR

瑜珈

2014年9月记：

我在这楼里介绍的spell to write and read (SWR) ，目前仍只有全英文教材，对一般家长来说，困难很大，请慎重购买。

如对这楼里介绍的方法感兴趣，请继续到这里了解我写的中文教材：

http://www.etjy.com/forum.php?mo ... &extra=page%3D1





phonics学习现在确实是一个热门话题，教材也是五花八门，种类繁多，我曾买过三种教材，第三次买到的spell to write and read (SWR) 才让我认识到，什么才是可靠的、全面的、有逻辑性的phonics。作者Wanda Sanseri 列举了一些其它教学法的不足之处，慢慢贴来。

(1)   Bogus Rules   

Some teach the cute sounding rule, "When two vowels go walking the first one does the talking." In other words, if we see two vowels together, the first one will say the name of the letter and the second one will be silent. (OA = /O/). Back in the '70s, I felt excited to learn this rule. My students marked page after page of words that illustrated this principle. The concept worked when we did screened worksheets, but in real life the rule failed repeatedly. I discovered why. The "two vowels going walking" rule works only 27% of the time. It only works consistently with oa, oe, ee, ay, ai. It never works with eu, ew, oy, oi, aw, au. It could, but usually does not, work with ey, ei, ou, ow, oo, ie, ui, ea, ear.

    The effective way to deal with vowel pairs is to teach each vowel team as a separate phonogram that the student recognizes instantly by sound. Our goal should be to establish the most instant response between the symbol and the sound, not to waste time with unfruitful mental gymnastics.

     A student can be taught all the sounds that EA regularly makes. Such a student is prepared for EA to say /E/ in bead, /e/ in head, /A/ in steak, and /er/ in learn. A student who learned the Two Vowels Go Walking rule might stumble over words like head, steak, and learn. People conclude, because of bogus rules like this, that English is so complex and is spelled so unpredictably that teaching phonics is useless. They don't understand that the problem is not the language, it is a faulty presentation of the language.

我的评论： "When two vowels go walking the first one does the talking."  这条伪规则在我第一次买的教材《星之升》之中就有，在starfall  这个网站的silly songs里也有，一个只有1/4 符合、3/4都是例外的规则还能叫做规则吗？家长千万别再把这条规则教给你的孩子了。

[ 本帖最后由 瑜珈 于 2011-12-24 21:27 编辑 ]

cangou

现在还是云里雾里，，，，继续努力

zlingyun

新手学习中

瑜珈

我在这楼里介绍的spell to write and read (SWR) ，目前仍只有全英文教材，对一般家长来说，困难很大，请慎重购买。

如对这楼里介绍的方法感兴趣，请继续到这里了解我写的中文教材：

http://www.etjy.com/forum.php?mo ... &extra=page%3D1

practice

现在买全套的的书和卡片还有吗，请站短告诉我好吗！谢谢！

yyailier

能否告知购书联系方式，谢谢

yyailier

麻烦瑜伽老师告知一下购买的方式和地址。谢谢了

2009蓝精灵

原帖由 <i>瑜珈</i> 于 2012-3-12 11:59 发表 <img src="http://bbs.etjy.com/images/common/back.gif" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt='Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor='hand'; this.alt='Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(this.src);}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt= />
一位坛友刚发给我的站短：

“瑜珈，您好！今天看到您在贴子里说新版SWR的出版会延期，但我又对这套书实在是喜欢，您能告知旧版的国内购书途径吗，你们在论坛里讨论的SWR里的内容，在我跟女儿学习的过程中起到 ...

瑜伽老师，
你好！
我现在有一本wise guide 现在急需spell to write and read,还能买到吗？

myfriend

我真钦佩各位家长！我是真的没有精力自己先学一通，再教给孩子。
邻居（也是中国人）家的老大上了kindergarten，我才从他妈妈那里听说“phonics"这个词，觉得我当初学的国际音标挺好的，可惜美国人真笨，完全不会。
等我孩子上学后，我去问问老师用的是不是SWR教材。
朋友给了2套她的两个孩子都用过的Phonics卡片，我的孩子天天拿来变魔术。
我的孩子已经4岁了，刚开始学写字母（注：我们在加州。）
我孩子在幼儿园有个要好的小朋友（父母都是中国人）刚开始上phonics课（我为了省钱当然没给报）。那个小朋友的妈妈每次接完孩子，就会问像can you draw something that starts with the sound "m" 的问题，我的孩子当然毫无反应。

Ruth1

天啊，感觉看说明都是那么困难。